Examining the Bankruptcy Trustee's Controversial "Clawback" Tool

Rick Kirby, Dr. Fred Dunbar, Dr. Marcia Kramer Mayer
The Madoff Ponzi scheme has brought intense scrutiny to a controversial tool of the bankruptcy trustee: the "clawback" of funds received from a bankrupt person or entity. Sometimes, as in the Madoff case, the people subject to the clawback are victims themselves.

Join us for a webcast that will look at the clawback in detail. Among other things, we'll discuss the law and precedent on when clawbacks are appropriate, how the trustee in the Madoff case and other cases such as Stanford and Westgate may apply the clawback provision, and how clawbacks can be fought off in certain situations. We'll also address related economic and policy issues such as tax loss, damages, and perceptions of equity.

Panelists include Rick Kirby, a partner in the securities litigation practice at K&L Gates; Dr. Fred Dunbar, Senior Vice President at NERA Economic Consulting; and Dr. Marcia Kramer Mayer, Senior Vice President at NERA Economic Consulting.
Mar 26 2009
73 mins
Examining the Bankruptcy Trustee's Controversial "Clawback" Tool
bankruptcy clawback
  • Channel
  • Channel profile
Up Down
  • Financial and Corporate Crime in the UK: Legal Trends and Developments Recorded: Apr 1 2014 58 mins
    This webcast features a panel discussion of recent UK legal developments in the field of corporate crime - in particular a focus on Deferred Prosecution Agreements, the related Prosecutors’ Code of Practice, the recent Sentencing Council guidelines for corporate offenders and confiscation in corporate crime cases.

    Our panel of speakers will offer their insights into these legal and financial issues: Satnam Tumani, Partner, Kirkland & Ellis, London; Jeffrey Bryant, Crown Advocate Proceeds of Crime Division, Crown Prosecution Service and Julian Glass, Managing Director, FTI Consulting, London.
  • Insider Trading Enforcement Update Recorded: Mar 11 2014 62 mins
    This webcast will highlight important recent developments in the government’s ongoing crackdown on insider trading, including lessons learned from recent high-profile criminal trials and debated legal issues. The panel will address:

    • The recent separate trials of former SAC Capital portfolio managers Mathew Martoma and Michael Steinberg in the Southern District of New York.
    • The effect prosecutions involving information from expert networks may have on the “mosaic theory.” Mosaic theory is the concept under which the SEC theoretically permits investors to piece together immaterial nonpublic information to form an investment thesis.
    • The sentences—usually no jail time—handed down to defendants who plead guilty and cooperate with the government’s investigation, versus the relatively long sentences of defendants who are convicted at trial.

    The speakers will include Lawrence Gerschwer, Partner, Morrison & Foerster LLP, and Allen D. Applbaum, Senior Managing Director and Global Leader of FTI Consulting’s Global Risk & Investigations Practice. Mssrs. Gerschwer and Applbaum are both former Assistant US Attorneys for the Southern District of New York.
  • How to Prove and Defend Fraudulent Transfer Claims:Legal & Valuation Perspective Recorded: Feb 12 2014 105 mins
    This webcast will consist of an analysis of the issues commonly confronted in fraudulent transfer litigation under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code and state law. The first portion of the program will provide attendees with an overview of the relevant legal aspects of the fraudulent transfer litigation, including discussion of:

    • Relevant provisions of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, including §548;
    • Bankruptcy Code § 544 and the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act;
    • Proving constructive fraud v. actual fraud; and
    • Recent developments in case law.

    The second half of the program will focus on valuation analyses often performed in conjunction with constructive fraud claims under §548 and state law, including:

    • Performing the balance-sheet test;
    • Assessing the adequacy of capital; and,
    • Analyzing the debtor’s ability to pay debts as they become due.

    A case study will be used during the program to highlight the legal and valuation issues.

    The program will be presented by litigation and bankruptcy attorneys Craig Simon and Dan Winikka from the law firm of Simon, Ray & Winikka LLP and valuation experts Jeff Litvak and Jack Schwager of FTI Consulting.
  • Global Anti-Corruption Enforcement & Compliance – 2013 Year in Review Recorded: Feb 3 2014 78 mins
    It has been another year of plenty for enforcement of the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (“FCPA”) and international anti-corruption statutes worldwide. From a return to the robust enforcement totals of recent years, to a nearly fourfold increase in the size of the average corporate fine, to increasingly aggressive deployment of traditional criminal investigative techniques, to the expansion of multi-jurisdictional, cross-border cooperation and prosecutions, 2013 marked another year of vigorous international anti-corruption enforcement.

    Featuring an experienced panel of anti-corruption and compliance practitioners, this webcast will provide an overview of the FCPA and a survey of anti-corruption enforcement, litigation, and policy developments from the past year, including those in the international arena, as well as provide the participant with practical tips for avoiding or minimizing liability under the FCPA and its foreign counterparts.
  • CFO Liability - the Toughest Job in Corporate America Recorded: Jan 28 2014 62 mins
    This webcast provides guidance for CFOs who face heightened scrutiny and liability as a result of the culmination of legislated rules and regulations, including Sarbanes-Oxley and Dodd-Frank. Newly enacted provisions provide for significant enhancement of SEC enforcement powers, coupled with heightened standards of liability for financial executives.

    In addition, the webcast highlights cases in which CFOs and other financial executives have been sanctioned for violations committed by their subordinates under a "should have known" standard. Finally, this webinar offers practical recommendations to assist CFOs in compliance with the increasingly complex regulations and requirements to which they are subjected.

    The speakers will include John J. Carney, co-leader of Baker Hostetler LLP's White-Collar and Corporate Investigations Group, Mark Gerber, PwC Partner, and Craig Carpenito, head of Alston & Bird's White-Collar Group. The intended audience is current CFOs, legal counsel for CFOs, and accountants working with CFOs.
  • SEC Enforcement: Key Developments in 2013 Recorded: Jan 8 2014 64 mins
    In this webcast analyzing key developments in SEC enforcement, our panel will discuss notable events from 2013 and emerging issues for 2014. Among other items, the panel will address:

    •The SEC’s shift towards requiring admissions, rather than no-admit-no-deny settlements;
    •The increased use of analytic technology to identify fraud;
    •The renewed focus on enforcement against “gatekeepers;”
    •Results of litigating with the SEC; and much more.

    Please join panelists Bill McLucas and Doug Davison, securities partners at Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP; and Marty Wilczynski and Jason Flemmons, Senior Managing Directors with FTI Consulting Forensic and Litigation Consulting, as they address these and other developments in SEC enforcement.
  • The FCPA Guidance After One Year: The Impact on Compliance and Practice Recorded: Dec 19 2013 64 mins
    It has now been a year since the DOJ and SEC released their long-awaited guidance on the FCPA, “A Resource Guide to the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.” The guidance provided user-friendly insight into how the government approaches FCPA enforcement, and set forth a number of factors companies should consider in evaluating their anti-corruption compliance programs and procedures.

    The FCPA guidance addressed a number of critical compliance concerns, including among others the use of third-party intermediaries, and the current state of parent/subsidiary and successor liability. It also created a one-stop resource for compliance personnel and affected business managers. The webcast will offer a practical and informed review of how the guidance has impacted FCPA practice generally, and more specifically how the guidance has affected compliance operations and the interaction of compliance professionals with both their business units and external counsel.
  • Navigating the Minefield of Dodd-Frank's Whistleblower Provisions and the FCPA Recorded: Dec 3 2013 75 mins
    We are in a brave new world of whistleblower regulation and litigation. Now three years after the passage of Dodd-Frank, the SEC Office of the Whistleblower is making an increasing number of bounty awards – including a recent record-breaking $14 million award – and federal courts across the country are defining and redefining the statute’s complex contours. Companies, meanwhile, continue to field the flood of hotline complaints in an effort to sift the chaff from tomorrow morning’s front-page expose. These trends, coupled with the continuing robust pace of FCPA enforcement, provide the perfect storm for keeping in-house counsel and compliance professionals up at night.

    Featuring an experienced panel of anti-corruption and compliance practitioners, this webcast will detail Dodd-Frank’s statutory and regulatory framework, discuss its early interpretations by the SEC Office of the Whistleblower and federal courts, and provide the participant with practical tips for navigating the minefield of whistleblower complaints.

    Please join F. Joseph Warin, partner, Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher; John Chesley, associate, Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher; and Jay Perlman, Director, Navigant as they address these issues and your questions in a free, one-hour webcast.
  • Financial Statements 101 – Accounting Fundamentals for Lawyers Recorded: Nov 6 2013 92 mins
    This webcast will cover fundamental concepts of accounting, focusing on issues that lawyers often encounter. Our panel of accounting experts will cover the three financial statements–balance sheet, income statement, and cash flows–and describe the components that are used to create them. In addition, our panel will cover how to derive meaningful conclusions from the data through ratio and trend analysis.

    In addition to understanding financial statements, this webcast will cover common Generally Accepted Accounting Principles and International Financial Reporting Standards.

    The panelists for this webcast are Jeff Litvak, CPA/ABV/CFF, ASA and Jack Schwager, CPA/ABV/CFF, CFE, both of FTI Forensic & Litigation Consulting.
  • Calculating Economic Damages in Commercial Litigation Cases Recorded: Oct 2 2013 94 mins
    This economic damages program will focus on a number of critical aspects to consider when calculating damages in a commercial litigation case. The first part of the program will deal with the following issues related to damage assessments:

    •Measurement of damages
    •Overview of damages
    •“But for” concept
    •Legal and other economic criteria to consider when proving damages
    •Discussion of the lost profit model
    •Discussion of the destruction of a business model

    The latter half of the program will deal with an actual case of proving damages for a new business. The case focuses on an e-retailing business who in the past lost in excess of $25 million in venture capital money and never sustained a profit. The new business had six months of positive contribution margins. The case discusses the challenges of proving damages for the new business and the defense’s position that the damages were speculative and flawed.

    The program will also include a review of the most recent case law on proving damages for a new business and the reasonable certainty standard in California.
  • The Supreme Court’s Decision in Amgen and Other Recent Securities Cases Recorded: Jul 24 2013 59 mins
    This year, on the heels of its rulings in Erica P. John Fund, Inc. v. Halliburton (2011) and Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes (2011), the Supreme Court has issued several opinions affecting securities fraud litigation. Of particular note, Amgen, Inc. v. Connecticut Retirement Plans and Trust Funds held that proof of materiality was not required at the class certification stage for an action based on the fraud on the market (FOTM) theory.

    This webcast will examine this recent Supreme Court decision, including the possible implications of four Justices suggesting a willingness to revisit whether the FOTM presumption of reliance is still proper. The Supreme Court’s possible willingness to revisit this theory could have a dramatic effect on securities litigation.

    This webcast also will discuss other recent Supreme Court cases and how they could affect parties in both private securities class actions and government enforcement actions:

    •Comcast Corp. v. Behrend, which required proof of classwide damages at the certification stage, may also affect securities class actions.

    •Gabelli v. SEC limited the “discovery rule” for statute of limitations to non-government enforcement actions.

    •The Court’s upcoming ruling in Chadbourne & Parke LLP v. Troice will address the scope of SLUSA’s “in connection with” requirement.
  • The UK Bribery Act Two Years On: What Was All the Fuss About? Recorded: Jul 2 2013 61 mins
    On July 1, 2013, the UK Bribery Act will mark its two-year anniversary. After the hype the question is: What was all the fuss about?

    In this webcast, a panel of leading UK lawyers and professionals will discuss the UK Bribery Act after its second birthday. This webcast is a “must attend” for general counsel, ethics officers and compliance counsel of any business affected by the UK Bribery Act. Don’t miss this opportunity to hear Vivian Robinson QC, former general counsel to the UK’s Serious Fraud Office and now a partner in McGuireWoods London; Barry Vitou, partner in Pinsent Masons LLP’s London office; Richard Kovalevsky QC, 2 Bedford Row; and Julian Glass, Managing Director, FTI Consulting answer your questions and address key topics, including:
    •Will the UK government water down the Bribery Act?
    •What is the likelihood of UK enforcement and when (if any) ?
    •What are the emerging trends?
    •Will deferred prosecution agreements make any difference?
    •Compliance benchmarking – what are other companies doing?
  • Financial Fraud Enforcement at the Crossroads: Which Way From Here? Recorded: Jun 25 2013 62 mins
    Since 2007, the number of SEC enforcement actions involving financial fraud has declined steadily each year—from a record 219 in 2007 down to just 94 in 2012. Over the period of this decline, numerous explanations have been offered by the SEC and other commentators, including the success of Sarbanes-Oxley in reducing restatements, shifting Enforcement Division priorities, the disbanding of the SEC’s “Financial Fraud Task Force,” and even the core metrics by which the SEC Enforcement Division’s performance is evaluated.

    The SEC has recently signaled that a renewed focus on financial fraud is imminent, with new analytical tools and an increased mobilization of resources. How this initiative is put into practice by the new SEC leadership could have important consequences for registrants, management, auditors and counsel.

    Please join us as we address these issues as well as your questions in a free, one-hour webcast that will analyze the past, present and future of financial fraud enforcement.
  • Navigating the Intersection of the FCPA, AML and Extraterritorial US Laws Recorded: Jun 18 2013 67 mins
    In a recent case the DOJ dubbed a “wake-up call,” the SEC and DOJ charged four individuals for their roles in a massive international bribery scheme, which the SEC discovered during a periodic examination of a broker-dealer. The agencies allege that employees of Direct Access Partners, LLC (“DAP”), a registered broker dealer, paid illicit bribes to high-ranking officials of Banco de Desarrollo Economico y Social de Venezuela (“BANDES”), the state-owned economic development bank of Venezuela. The action illustrates how conduct that has traditionally formed the basis of a Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (“FCPA”) case might also subject individuals and entities to a much broader array of charges under US law, including charges under anti-money laundering laws and the Travel Act.

    Join an experienced panel of government enforcement experts to learn how multi-national organizations in all industries can ensure that they have developed and implemented robust compliance programs that address these overlapping regulatory schemes.
  • The Internal Audit Function and Anti-Corruption Compliance Recorded: Jun 13 2013 92 mins
    The continuing surge of FCPA enforcement is but one pitfall that the internal audit function is tasked with avoiding, and the list of pitfalls just keeps growing. These days, internal audit functions face increased expectations from a wide variety of constituencies, and the stakes are high: failures can mean SEC and DOJ actions which name internal auditors as defendants or as those who could have prevented that high-visibility settlement.

    Featuring an experienced panel of anti-corruption, internal audit, and compliance practitioners, this webcast will detail the current statutory, regulatory, and standards-based framework within which internal auditors function, discuss the increasingly dynamic and complex role of internal audit, explore the successes and failures of internal audit functions through the lens of FCPA enforcement actions, and provide practical tips for establishing a successful relationship between internal audit and compliance functions.
  • ESI Meets CSI:What Every Lawyer Should Know About Technology & Digital Forensics Recorded: May 23 2013 64 mins
    Whether conducting an internal investigation, engaged in an adversarial dispute or handling a criminal, civil or regulatory enforcement matter, today’s legal practitioners strive to provide definitive answers to critical data-related questions: What sort of digital DNA can turn the tides for a defendant? Did a witness spoliate or tamper with digital evidence? What thought-to-be-deleted evidence can be recovered from the unallocated or slack space of a computer, phone or tablet? What should counsel do when the SEC or some other government entity subpoenas a client’s hard drive? What are the technological threats posed by so-called “bad leavers (i.e. disgruntled former employees who seek revenge against their former employers)? These are just a few of the questions covered by this presentation which will not only enlighten even the most tech-savvy attorney but will also help attendees avoid the kind of data-handling failures that can result in malpractice claims, disbarment or even worse, prosecution for an obstruction-related crime.

    This webinar will feature John Reed Stark – John founded and served for 11 years as Chief of the SEC’s Office of Internet Enforcement; taught technology and law courses at Georgetown Law School for 15 years; and now serves as a Managing Director at Stroz Friedberg, a digital risk management firm that specializes in digital forensics, data breach & cybercrime response, electronic discovery, business intelligence & investigation and security risk consulting. An expert in particular on handling DOJ and SEC data-related matters and on combating bad leavers, John will address these issues and your questions throughout his discussion.
  • Shareholder Efforts to Improve Transparency of Corporate Political Spending Recorded: Apr 3 2013 69 mins
    This webcast, the latest in BLB&G's Webcast Series for Institutional Investors, focuses on the latest developments in efforts to achieve disclosure of corporate political spending.

    In Citizens United v. FEC, the United States Supreme Court made it easier for corporate directors and executives to use company funds - shareholder assets - to support political candidates or causes. In response to Citizens United, the institutional investor community has urged public companies to enhance their disclosures of political spending.

    Because compliance is voluntary, however, these efforts cannot account for the companies for whom disclosure is most important - those who have something to hide in their political spending. Without meaningful regulation from the SEC or legal precedent to require public disclosures, shareholder efforts to improve transparency faced a roadblock.

    Since Summer 2012, BLB&G's Corporate Governance team, working on behalf of the New York State Common Retirement Fund, pursued a novel alternative for addressing this problem - a Section 220 books and records request. The Fund demanded that technology giant Qualcomm Inc. provide the Fund with corporate books and records reflecting its prior political spending. While Section 220 is regularly used by shareholders seeking to investigate corporate malfeasance, it had never before been used to obtain disclosure of corporate political spending.

    After Qualcomm refused to provide the Fund with the requested books and records, BLB&G filed a lawsuit on behalf of the Fund to enforce its rights under Section 220. On February 22, 2013, Qualcomm adopted a Political Contributions and Expenditures Policy that will provide its shareholders with comprehensive disclosures regarding the Company's political activities.

    The Fund and BLB&G may have broken important new ground that can help the shareholder community obtain more fulsome disclosure of corporate political spending.
  • Earnouts in M&A Transactions -- Emerging Trends Recorded: Mar 21 2013 90 mins
    This webcast will introduce participants to the basics of the earnout as an element of the purchase price in M&A transactions and the common disputes that arise from earnout provisions.

    The panel will discuss the intricacies of earnouts, legal considerations and recent case law relating to earnouts, the mechanics of earnouts, common disputes involving earnouts, the valuation and recognition of earnouts, and more. This program will also address the role of the neutral accounting arbitrator in resolving an earnout dispute.

    The program is geared to lawyers involved in mergers and acquisitions.

    Please join panelists Jeff Litvak and Jeremy McGannon, both of FTI Consulting’s Forensic and Litigation Consulting practice, and Jim Rolfes of Reed Smith as they address these issues and your questions in this free webcast.
  • FATCA Final Regulations: The Clock is Ticking Recorded: Mar 14 2013 54 mins
    The due diligence requirements for new and pre-existing accounts are now set and deadlines are quickly approaching. There are less than 10 months until FATCA goes live and foreign financial institutions across the globe need to start getting ready now. FATCA’s Final Regulations and the model intergovernmental agreements (“IGAs”), although complex when first read, can be simplified to make implementation more efficient.

    In this complimentary webcast, Navigant’s FATCA experts Richard Kando and Jeffrey Locke will discuss concrete steps, challenges and best practices that all financial institutions need to know to successfully operationalize FATCA’s due diligence requirements.
  • Recent Trends in Merger & Acquisition Disputes Recorded: Feb 27 2013 98 mins
    The recent downturn in the economy has been a factor in recent disputes arising from business acquisitions. Some involve a failure to close a transaction, but many are over claims of fraud, misrepresentation or breach of warranties or covenants after a transaction has closed. In these types of disputes, the most important question is whether a party will be entitled to seek damages and, if so, the manner in which the damages are to be measured. After the dust settles, however, other questions arise, including: how did we get here and how can we prevent this in the future?

    The session will provide insight into recent trends in mergers and acquisitions following the economic downturn as well as observations and insights into the types of disputes that have emerged in this economy. In this context, the session will provide background on the legal and transactional issues that must be considered during negotiations, drafting of the transactional documents, closing and beyond and an overview of the various legal, accounting, and valuation aspects of disputes over misrepresentations, breaches, earnouts and post-closing adjustments.

    Please join our panelists Daniel Delaney, Partner in Drinker, Biddle & Reath LLP’s Commercial Litigation Group; and Jeff Litvak, Senior Managing Director, and Nicole Wells, Managing Director in FTI’s Forensic and Litigation Consulting Practice as they address these issues as well as your questions.
Timely webcasts and updates for lawyers and other professionals
Timely webcasts, analysis, updates and presentations about securities litigation, SEC enforcement and white collar issues. This channel allows listeners to learn about cutting-edge issues from the leading attorneys, consultants, and other professionals in the securities litigation industry.

Embed in website or blog

Successfully added emails: 0
Remove all
  • Title: Examining the Bankruptcy Trustee's Controversial "Clawback" Tool
  • Live at: Mar 26 2009 6:00 pm
  • Presented by: Rick Kirby, Dr. Fred Dunbar, Dr. Marcia Kramer Mayer
  • From:
Your email has been sent.
or close
You must be logged in to email this